“Do you know what the difference between you and me is?” snarled the bearded man to whom I had not said a single word and whose only word to me up to this point had been “faggot”.

“What’s that?” I asked.

“I know who my mother and father are.”

You may be wondering what would compel a grown man to direct such a vitriolic comment at a complete stranger on a public sidewalk in New York City. The answer is quite simple: I had had the temerity to be present and to photograph this man as he waved two live chickens above the heads of his female companions (presumably his wife and daughter) during the ritual animal sacrifice known as kaporos.

This was my third year documenting kaporos in Brooklyn, so I’m no stranger to the hostility to outsiders that characterizes so many of the practitioners of this ancient and barbaric ritual. When I have documented kaporos in the past, I have been insulted, yelled at, and threatened, so I wasn’t expecting a warm reception this year. Nevertheless, the level of aggression at this year’s kaporos was palpably higher than in years past.

Of course, I could have left at any point and spared myself the frustration of being berated by (mostly unmasked) strangers; but as there was no possible escape for most of the unfortunate chickens for whom I had come to bear witness, I decided that I had no right to give myself any such easy way out of what was for me, an extremely unpleasant situation, but what for the animals, was a truly horrific one. So, I stayed and documented the event.

This is what I saw. This is kaporos.

A truck full of live chickens arrives at the site where the ritual slaughter will take place, a mostly residential neighborhood in Crown Heights, Brooklyn.

Once unloaded, the crates are piled on top of each other on the sidewalk. The job of retrieving the chickens from the crates and handing them to the congregants is entrusted, for the most part, to children. New York State law prohibits persons below… — Once unloaded, the crates are piled on top of each other on the sidewalk. The job of retrieving the chickens from the crates and handing them to the congregants is entrusted, for the most part, to children. New York State law prohibits persons below the age of 18 to be employed in a slaughterhouse, but in this makeshift slaughter facility on a public sidewalk in New York City, this and other laws and ordinances are conveniently not enforced by the numerous NYPD officers who are present throughout the event. Mayor Bill de Blasio is also fully aware of what goes on at these events and has made no effort to stop them and every effort to accommodate them. The two words he invokes to defend his complicity in this primitive ritual of blood sacrifice are “religious freedom”. If he were speaking truthfully on the matter, however, the two words he would use are “voting bloc”.

Each of these crates contains about ten chickens. As the crates are emptied, new ones are brought in by truck to replenish the supply of victims.

A man waves two live and very distraught chickens above the heads of his female companions as they read a prayer that has been taped to one of numerous metal barricades thoughtfully provided by the New York City Police Department for this event that… — A man waves two live and very distraught chickens above the heads of his female companions as they read a prayer that has been taped to one of numerous metal barricades thoughtfully provided by the New York City Police Department for this event that violates numerous state laws and local ordinances.

No apparent efforts are made to shield children from the unpleasantness and cruelty toward animals involved in kaporos. On the contrary, many of them are conscripted as participants in the antiquated and bloody ritual sacrifice. Most children exhibi… — No apparent efforts are made to shield children from the unpleasantness and cruelty toward animals involved in kaporos. On the contrary, many of them are conscripted as participants in the antiquated and bloody ritual sacrifice. Most children exhibit a natural aversion to animal abuse, so it’s easy to imagine how upsetting it must be for many of them to witness it firsthand and perpetrated by people they know and trust.

Oh look, you just got a text message! It’s from the Dark Ages. They’d like their violent and obscurantist ritual back.

Notice the lack of feathers on this chicken’s breast and keel. Because these animals spend most of their short lives in filthy, crowded facilities that aren’t properly or frequently cleaned, they are forced to live in and directly on large quantitie… — Notice the lack of feathers on this chicken’s breast and keel. Because these animals spend most of their short lives in filthy, crowded facilities that aren’t properly or frequently cleaned, they are forced to live in and directly on large quantities of excrement. Prolonged and direct exposure to the ammonia from all of that fecal matter literally burns the feathers off of parts of their bodies. Just try to imagine the pain it causes to their exposed skin.

The phrase that the practitioners of kaporos are supposed to say as they wave a chicken above their heads is “This is my exchange, this is my substitute, this is my atonement. This rooster (hen) will go to its [sic] death, while I will enter and pro… — The phrase that the practitioners of kaporos are supposed to say as they wave a chicken above their heads is “This is my exchange, this is my substitute, this is my atonement. This rooster (hen) will go to its [sic] death, while I will enter and proceed to a good long life and to peace.” The doctrine of substitutionary atonement is morally appalling, even when the “substitute” is a willing participant in the transaction. But when the substitute is an innocent, defenseless, and unconsenting victim, it’s even more appalling still. Why should someone who bears no responsibility whatsoever for someone else’s sins be sacrificed as an atonement for them?

These inverted traffic cones are where the chickens’ lives will end. After their throats are hastily slit, they are placed head-down into the cones and left to bleed out. Chickens sometimes manage to escape from the cones, even though they are morta… — These inverted traffic cones are where the chickens’ lives will end. After their throats are hastily slit, they are placed head-down into the cones and left to bleed out. Chickens sometimes manage to escape from the cones, even though they are mortally wounded. But their struggle is in vain. Once they’ve had the knife drawn across their throats, there is no hope of survival.

It’s difficult to imagine how stressful and terrifying this sadistic ritual must be for the tens of thousands of chickens who are abused and slaughtered in kaporos every year.

During a pandemic that has killed over a million people worldwide and over 23,000 in New York City alone, and which was caused by a zoonotic disease, the mayor of New York City, the feckless and almost universally despised Bill de Blasio, permits th… — During a pandemic that has killed over a million people worldwide and over 23,000 in New York City alone, and which was caused by a zoonotic disease, the mayor of New York City, the feckless and almost universally despised Bill de Blasio, permits thousands of live birds to be stacked in crates on public sidewalks in the densely populated borough of Brooklyn. The threat to public health caused by this situation is of little or no apparent concern to Mr. de Blasio.

Almost without exception, the people who take part in kaporos hold the chickens as this person is doing: with the birds’ fragile wings pinned together behind their backs and held as one would hold a grocery bag. Every indication is that this is incr… — Almost without exception, the people who take part in kaporos hold the chickens as this person is doing: with the birds’ fragile wings pinned together behind their backs and held as one would hold a grocery bag. Every indication is that this is incredibly painful for the birds, especially when it happens, as it does often in kaporos, for prolonged periods.

This is a recording of chickens crying as they are lifted from crates by their sensitive wings.

I think this guy has a crush on me. He kept following me around and asking me questions as he filmed me with his phone. And for some reason, he kept yelling that I hate Jews, which was a lie. I don’t hate Jews. I hate animal abuse. He also made the … — I think this guy has a crush on me. He kept following me around and asking me questions as he filmed me with his phone. And for some reason, he kept yelling that I hate Jews, which was a lie. I don’t hate Jews. I hate animal abuse. He also made the slanderous and utterly false assertion that I stole a chicken. None of this is surprising. Anyone who thinks it’s perfectly acceptable to abuse animals isn’t likely to have many scruples when it comes to defamation of character. Anyway, if you know this guy, please tell him that I’m flattered by all of his attention, but I’m just not interested. I don’t date non-vegans.

No one deserves to be treated like this. If you were in her position, wouldn’t you want someone fighting for you?

This photo is my tribute to the political legacy of Mayor Bill de Blasio. I call it “CHICKENSHIT”.

Some people think animal abuse is funny. It isn’t. Don’t be one of those people.

For some of the chickens slaughtered in this horrific ritual, there was at least some reprieve. In an effort organized by Slaughter-Free NYC, a group of animal rights activists came to the site of the kaporos ritual and gave water and fruit to as ma… — For some of the chickens slaughtered in this horrific ritual, there was at least some reprieve. In an effort organized by Slaughter-Free NYC, a group of animal rights activists came to the site of the kaporos ritual and gave water and fruit to as many of the birds as they could. Of course, this did not spare the birds the fate that awaited them, but it provided some solace and meant that these sensitive creatures wouldn’t die without having experienced some measure of human kindness.

An animal rights activist uses her phone to capture the plight of chickens destined for slaughter in kaporos.

What You Can Do

If you live in New York City and you’re concerned by what you’ve seen in this blogpost, call 311 and let the city officials know that you find ritual animal sacrifice on public property unacceptable. When you call 311, you will be asked when and where the incident you’re reporting happened. All of the photos above were taken on Saturday, September 26th, 2020 on Eastern Parkway Boulevard and Kingston Avenue in the Crown Heights neighborhood of Brooklyn.
If you know anyone who practices kaporos with a live chicken, please suggest the much more popular and humane alternative of using cash instead.
Learn more about the effort to end the use of chickens in kaporos by visiting endchickensaskaporos.com and United Poultry Concerns.
Support the work of Slaughter-Free NYC. These people work tirelessly to educate the public about the horrors of kaporos and other forms of animal abuse and slaughter in New York City.
Don’t eat chickens. Chickens are the most exploited land animals on the planet. In the United States alone, 9 billion of them are killed for food every year, which is an average of 28 chickens for every man, woman, and child in the country, every single year. By not eating them, you remove the incentive for the producers of chicken-based products to keep breeding more of them into existence for the sole purpose of slaughter.
Visit a sanctuary! Every year, animal liberation activists manage to rescue hundreds of chickens from kaporos sites around the world. Many of these birds wind up at amazing sanctuaries, where they receive top-notch veterinary care and lots and lots of TLC. At sanctuaries such as Tamerlaine Animal Sanctuary and Woodstock Farm Sanctuary, you can meet and get to know chickens who have been rescued from kaporos rituals and are now living happy, healthy lives with other chickens and their human guardians.

2 Comments

If you're not one for open-air slaughterhouses, the overpowering stench of blood and feces on the streets and sidewalk, and the sound of terrified animals having their throats slit in the presence and with the assistance of children, then maybe New York City just isn't the place for you. For that is the distressing and anachronistic scene at an annual event that takes place in the Crown Heights neighborhood of Brooklyn, in which an estimated sixty-thousand young chickens are jammed into plastic crates, shipped into the city on trucks, left on the sidewalk without food or water, and then summarily slaughtered in an atavistic and violent atonement ritual known as kaporos.

Your first thought may be that such an overtly unsanitary and unhygienic and morally appalling festival must certainly be illegal in the Capital of The Modern World in the year 2016, and indeed it is illegal. The ritual sacrifice of live animals as described above and practiced within the city limits of New York violates no fewer than fifteen city and state public health and safety laws and statutes regarding cruelty to animals. And yet, it is an annual occurrence that the NYPD does not merely tolerate, but positively supports. Every year the NYPD and the mayor's office not only fail to enforce the very laws that it is their sworn duty and solemn responsibility to uphold, but are also complicit in the breaking of those laws by providing manpower, barricades, and generators to aid and abet the practitioners of these flagrantly illegal activities: activities that are a threat to public health and public safety and are also unimaginably painful and traumatic to the animals involved.

This disgraceful and inhumane practice must end now. And so must the willingness of the New York City Police Department and Mayor deBlasio to look the other way and grant impunity to those whose attachment to an obscure and violent religious tradition is being allowed to imperil public health and public safety and to subvert the laws that protect nonhuman animals from agonizing cruelty. The desire of a few small religious sects to adhere to the barbaric practice of sacrificing live animals in order to atone for their sins should not put other New Yorkers in the position of having to sacrifice our health, safety, and decency at the altar of religious tolerance.

Below are photographs that Vegan Future Now took at this year's kaporos ritual in Crown Heights, Brooklyn. Hovering over each photo with your cursor will reveal a description of the image.